Sign up for the Nieman Storyboard newsletter, delivered every Friday in your inbox.
***
Dear Storyboard community,
This November marks 30 years since the first episode of “This American Life,” which forever changed storytelling for radio (and later, podcasting). In those three decades, host and co-creator Ira Glass has dispensed many memorable and quotable lessons on the craft. For example, there’s a whole genre of YouTube videos dedicated to Glass’s thoughts on the “taste-talent gap.”
Now here’s one more, from a wonderful new interview with Talk Easy’s Sam Fragoso (hat-tip Julie Shapiro) that’s both succinct and will make you rethink every lede you ever wrote or plan to write:
The format of “This American Life” is designed around this thing that [Roland Barthes] calls the proairetic code. And the proairetic code is basically this simple principle that if you have any sequence of actions start, no matter how banal, [with] “This thing happens and it leads to this next thing, and it leads to this next thing,” even if all the things are very ordinary. [For example,] ”a man wakes up and the house seems very quiet, and he walks to the door of the bedroom and just listens for a second, and the house is very quiet. He walks down the stairs; the house is very quiet.”
Nothing is happening in this story, actually. It's all, like, super banal, but you feel the forward motion of a story happening and you can feel the intentionality and you start to wonder what will happen next. And he says that any sequence of actions that you get going will create the question, ”Where are we going?”
And that's just incredibly useful. That's one of the reasons why “This American Life” just starts in motion.
'TAL' producer Nadia Reiman on storytelling with agency
To see that theory in action, here’s the opening of Act Two of the latest (and 859th) episode of “This American Life," in which Pulitzer Prize-winning producer Nadia Reiman introduces us to a young woman recording her fiancé as he gives himself a tattoo on his stomach.
The woman, Mari, retails a list of all the “ridiculous” art he has on his body — foreshadowing what we already sense is coming:
Reiman: When Mari shows me this video, it feels like something I'm not supposed to be watching. On the screen is her fiancé, Mikael. He's shirtless. He's crisply lined up. He's young, 23, bright green eyes, wild curly hair tucked under a baseball cap, and he's holding a tattoo gun, giving himself a tattoo on his stomach while she teases him, says he's never going to tattoo her again.
[MIKAEL LAUGHING]
He looks up and laughs, his mouth full of braces. Mari is always sort of dragging Mikael about his tattoos. He has lots of them, some which Mari finds offensively dumb.
Mari
[SPEAKING SPANISH]
Interpreter
He has a Mickey Mouse, but the Mickey Mouse is smoking. He used to smoke, and he used to do ridiculous things like that, because to me, they're ridiculous things. But yeah.
And then behind that, he has a little hand, like a little hand with an eye. And he tells me that eye sees everything. And I was just like, bueno, OK.
Mari
[SPEAKING SPANISH]
Interpreter
And he has something else there, like just — like an ugly doll, like it looks like a toad. It has big eyes.
Mari
[SPEAKING SPANISH]
Nadia Reiman
It's E.T. smoking a blunt. Mari is not her real name. She's from Venezuela. She's here applying for asylum, which is legal, but that seems to matter less and less nowadays in terms of who gets deported, hence the alias.
Mikael, who had also applied for asylum, was arrested by unidentified officers — presumably from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) or working with them. Mari later spotted him in a video among the 238 Venezuelan migrants who were taken out of the U.S. and sent to the CECOT prison in El Salvador.
As Reiman reports, “Mari is convinced that Mikael's tattoos, that's the only reason the government thinks he's a gang member, which is not crazy. The government is looking at tattoos. They have a list of Tren de Aragua suspicious tattoos, and it is broad — trains, crowns, roses, clocks, star, a Michael Jordan. If this is a list of gang tattoos, everyone under 50 is in a gang.”
Reiman told me she discovered Mari and Mikael's story while working on a different "TAL" piece, "our ‘Museum of Now’ show, which was supposed to be about artifacts that say something about the moment. I was interested in people who found out where their loved ones were through a video of some sort. So I asked around immigration lawyers and wanted to know if any of them had clients who had experienced this. Mikael's lawyer told me about Mari and put me in touch with her."
When I talked to her I liked how she was able to describe things in scenes. She also was so open and direct — and just so young. Such a picture of most of the folks affected by this CECOT thing. While at the same time she was so ACTIVE. She did so much — she found the lawyer, she talked to her boss. She's a person with a lot of agency and motion, so that made her a solid character to me. Someone I wanted to get to know.
As for Glass's comments about starting stories in motion, Reiman said:
I am what I would call a plot jock, so it's hard for me to think about how to start a story without thinking about the action that happens first, what happens next … and almost all of my stories are structured chronologically. For this one, we started with the tattoo tape simply because it was a scene that said something about Mari and Mikael's dynamic as a couple. And Mari's eye-rolling about his tattoos helps you know them and picture them in a real and funny way before you get to what happened to them. Otherwise I think it's too easy for stories of people that went through something traumatic to feel truly 3-D. If you start straight with the police coming, they become characters that something happens to, rather than full people with agency. So that was the thought behind that.
Storytelling is a puzzle, and the care Reiman takes to center her subjects' agency and humanity makes it all the more impactful.
Links of note
- Barry Yeoman, whose newsletter tipped me off to Reiman's latest "TAL" piece, calls narrative and investigative journalism “the second draft of history.” He rounds up a must-read list of stories that are now coming out of Trump's second term.
- "To write long, first write short." After years as an editor, Laurie Hertzel discovered that blogging helped her start writing again. "I made it a habit, writing each morning for about 20 minutes over breakfast. I wrote about small things: our dogs, our garden, my job. I made each entry a story." That habit helped her shape ideas that became books, including "News to Me: Adventures of an Accidental Journalist," and the forthcoming "Ghosts of Fourth Street" (via Storyboard editor emerita Jacqui Banaszynski).
- "The 30 best nonfiction books of the last 30 years." An outstanding list from the Los Angeles Times staff, and a great reminder of all the different ways we tell true stories. (Tell me your own favorites, or what's missing from this list: editor@niemanstoryboard.org.)
Keep sharing your stories,
Mark Armstrong
Editor
Nieman Storyboard
Follow the Nieman Storyboard Podcast
On Bluesky: @niemanstoryboard.org
Subscribe to Storyboard
Get insights into the craft of journalism and storytelling in your inbox, delivered on Fridays.
Follow the Nieman Storyboard Podcast
[ Follow us in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast app. ]